I’m about tired of this discussion, so let’s break it all the way down, and put this one to bed for good.
1st and 10, ball at the 26. Cajuns up 14-7, 9:54 2Q. Troy just had a turnover on downs. Cajuns scored TD’s on their first 2/3 drives with Lunch at QB… Enter Walker Howard.
Before we begin, typically a TE quick out/hitch is a one read pass play. This can also be an option route, where the TE reads the OLBs positioning, and has the option to run either an out or a hitch. On this particular play, you can see the outside WR on a free release by the CB, who is playing zone. The CB sat on the route by Caden, timed his hit perfectly, leading to both a ‘pick 6’ and an injury to our starting TE. It was a great play by the CB, but that’s not the issue here.
Let’s review Des comments:
Comment 1: '“It was the right decision, right read”
Comment 2: “The route, depth, and timing wasn’t perfect”
Comment 1… As mentioned, the CB released the outside WR on this play, played zone, and sat on the route by the TE in the flats. That fact alone IMMEDIATELY makes this the wrong read. If you review the photo I posted, the ball was already thrown, and is shown as a blur just above the SBC logo. If that ball was thrown to the WR, which would have actually been the right read, it would have been a 15 yard gain and a first down.
Comment 2… IF Caden actually ran the incorrect route… THAT ALSO MAKES IT THE WRONG READ! At worst, Howard should have tucked and ran for what he could, and moved on the the next play. Instead, he locked on to the TE route immediately, didn’t see the CB release his man and sit down in the flats, and then threw a hospital ball for 6 points the other way.
I’m baffled that anybody else with common football knowledge can’t see these facts. Am I missing something here?